Meet
Beard Papa’s
Not many foreign quick-serves have made the jump from
overseas success to prominence here in the United States. One Japanese
pastry chain is trying. By Aaron Dalton
In 2004, New Yorkers got their first view of Beard
Papa and his puff pastries filled with vanilla cream. In Japan, both the
icon and his baked wares are a phenomenal success; here in the States,
they are just starting to make their presence known.
So, let us give you a little background.
“There is no real-life Beard Papa. He is a
fictional character,” explains Minoru Inagaki, president of the U.S.
division of Japanese conglomerate Muginoho which owns Beard Papa’s.
“When our company’s founder, Mr. Yuji Hirota, created our logo,
he wanted to choose something that would bring people the cheerful,
energetic mood associated with the Christmas holidays. So he chose a
Santa-like character, but then changed the color of his outfit from red to
yellow to signify that you can be in a joyful holiday mood all year at
Beard Papa’s.”
Just seven years after Hirota founded Muginoho and
five years after Beard Papa was born, the quick-service chain now has 260
stores worldwide. In addition to its Japanese base of approximately 200
stores, Beard Papa’s also operates in China, Korea, Singapore, Hong
Kong, and now the United States.
How Beard Papa’s came to the U.S. is a story in
itself. For years, travelers to Japan had relished the sweet treat of a
Beard Papa’s cream puff. They would buy boxes of them to consume on plane rides back to the States—though
the preservative-free puffs didn’t last much past the plane rides,
making it easier to rationalize devouring the whole box in flight.
One such traveler was Nobuko Ogihara, a Tokyo native
living in New York City. On a trip to Tokyo in 2001, Ogihara saw a line of
people waiting outside a Beard Papa’s shop and so she did what
Japanese shoppers tend to do when they see a queue outside an unfamiliar
food establishment: she joined the end of the queue to see what could be so
good. Finding the cream puff treat worth the wait, Ogihara felt sure that
Americans would appreciate the joys of Beard Papa’s just as much as
the Japanese and started to wonder why Beard Papa’s hadn’t
already expanded to the States.
In fact, Beard Papa’s management had thought of
expanding to the U.S. market for some time, but lacking the language
skills, local market knowledge, and bureaucratic expertise, they had
decided to build their operations closer to home until a suitable
opportunity arose. Ogihara presented just such an opportunity. She
contacted Muginoho’s corporate offices in Japan and offered to help
the brand set up operations in New York City. As a densely populated urban
market with plenty of Japanese expatriates and lots of experience with
Japanese cuisine, New York was attractive as a U.S. base of operations from
several angles. (Management had also considered other major metro areas
like Los Angeles and Chicago as potential U.S. launch sites.) Ogihara flew
to Osaka, Japan and made a presentation to the Muginoho board of directors
in which she outlined the potential of the U.S. market in general and the
New York market in particular. Hirota and the Muginoho board approved of
her plans and began working with her on transferring the Beard Papa’s
brand halfway around the world.
That was 2002. Today, Beard Papa’s enjoys a loyal
and growing New York customer base, helped by friendly reviews from the
critics. The company opened its first New York store in March 2004, its
second store in September, and has plans to open 50 U.S. stores within the
next two years, largely through franchising.
It was not easy to get to this point, however. In the
two years between the time Beard Papa’s decided to come to the States
and the time it opened its first store, the company needed to overcome two
major challenges—penetrate the tough New York urban real estate
market and adjust operations for unfamiliar territory.
“No one knew about us. In New York, a company
doesn’t go out and ask for Main Street and Broadway unless it’s
Starbucks.”
On the real estate end, Beard Papa’s encountered
trouble due to the mismatch between its status and its goals. The company
felt it needed a high-traffic location to generate enough revenue off a
$1.25 pastry to meet high real estate costs. Because the company
didn’t want to have to spend a lot right away on marketing costs, it
also needed the location to be visible enough to serve as its own
billboard. The problem was that even though the company was well known
overseas, it had no name recognition yet in the U.S. markets. Accordingly,
many New York real estate brokers were reluctant to take the
company’s search seriously.
“No one knew about us,” says Inagaki.
“In New York, a company doesn’t go out and ask for Main Street
and Broadway unless it’s Starbucks. A lot of real estate agents did
not take us seriously at first. They told us to pay a full year’s
deposit for the space. We did not have a reputation yet. Of course, as soon
as our first store was open and people saw the line out the door for creampuffs,
everyone wanted to be our best friend.”
Needless to say, Beard Papa’s no longer has
trouble being taken seriously and negotiating for prime real estate. Its
first 800-square-foot location sits in a high traffic area, a main avenue
(Broadway) between two subway stops on the residential Upper West Side of
Manhattan. Its second 900-square-foot store will be situated in Astor Place,
a downtown neighborhood with a strong Japanese expatriate and multicultural
hipster presence.
In addition to the space issues, Beard Papa’s
also faced operational hurdles. Perhaps more than in some other countries,
business in Japan is tied into a social network. Companies place great
emphasis on personal recommendations and connections in finding suppliers.
While Beard Papa’s had a dependable network in its Asian hub, it took
time to build those same connections here. As president of Muginoho USA,
Inagaki was charged with finding construction firms to build the new stores,
designers to furnish it, dairy companies and sugar companies to supply the
raw ingredients.
Besides finding suppliers, Beard Papa’s also
needed to fine-tune its operations for its new market. Even the electrical
voltage differs between the U.S. and Japan, so the company’s baking
equipment and prep times needed to be altered to conform to the realities
of the U.S. infrastructure.
Beard Papa’s hit on an innovative way to ease
into its U.S. operations and gain valuable experience while minimizing risk
and keeping a low profile. The company made a deal with a single unit
Midtown Manhattan café called Zaiya that caters to a Japanese
clientele. Zaiya agreed that Beard Papa’s could carve out a section
of its store and set up a mini store-within-a-store operation. It was a
win-win arrangement for both parties: Beard Papa’s could hit the
ground running by training employees, adjusting operations, and building a
brand presence before even opening its first real store. Zaiya could
generate additional foot traffic for its other products from customers who
felt nostalgia for their home country’s brand. Though Beard
Papa’s plans to open only stand-alone stores from now on, the Zaiya
kiosk remains open as a acknowledgement, say Beard Papa executives, of the
role Zaiya played in helping Beard Papa become established stateside.
Inagaki also had the responsibility of staffing U.S.
operations in a way that would meet Beard Papa’s high standards of
service. In Japan, customers expect quick-service workers to provide a
level of courtesy, professionalism, and deference that far surpasses what
is asked of U.S workers. “We try to do everything for the
customer,” says Inagaki. “We don’t see ourselves really
here to sell cream puffs—we are here to sell a service. When the
customer walks into the store, we engage his five senses. You can smell the
cream puffs baking all day long. You feel the fresh shell of the cream
puffs, and you taste them when you bite in. You can see and hear the
servers talking to you and to each other so it’s important that they
are very upbeat and enthusiastic. We tell our staff that when they are
behind the counter, they are not there to sell cream puffs—they are
actually performers on stage who are being watched making cream puffs. When
the customer is done seeing the performance, he gets to go home and take
the cream puff that he watched being made. The cream puff is just something
to take home. It’s an extra treat.”
Going forward, staffing will continue to be a
challenge for Beard Papa. So far, many of the company’s U.S.
employees are Japanese or Japanese-American, simply because the company has
largely advertised for employees in Japanese-language outlets. Still, as
the company grows, Beard Papa’s will obviously need to diversify to
meet U.S. employment laws. Franchisees will be encouraged to hire a diverse
group of employees to both represent and attract a diverse customer base.
Still, the company says it is confident that its
training program for both staff and managers will allow it to maintain the
same high levels of friendly service and quality production. “We are
very demanding from our staff, but then again, we also make Beard
Papa’s a very fun place to work,” says Inagaki.
“It’s going to be very rewarding, because we are at a point
where we are growing and franchising very aggressively. So it will be easy
for employees to move up to managerial and even owner levels. If you work
hard, you will be recruited to a new store.”
Here in the U.S., Beard Papa’s has decided to
use its first corporate-run Beard Papa’s store as an outlet to test
items that Muginoho sells through three distinct brands back in
Japan—items like mango sorbet and cheesecake sticks. In Japan,
Muginoho sells the shaved ice mango products through a brand called
Oriental Beauty and the cheesecake sticks through its Tio Gluton (Fat
Uncle) brand. In fact, Muginoho runs a number of specialized quick-service
operations in Japan—savory crepe stores,
yakitori (BBQ chicken on skewers) outlets,
noodle shops—as well as various upscale restaurants and a Cuban salsa
club. However, here in the States, the plan is to focus on the Beard
Papa’s brand for now and, more specifically, on the cream puff.
Outside of the testing and training store, Beard Papa’s will carry
only cream puffs and related cream-filled items such as cannolis.
Even the electrical voltage differs, so the company’s
baking equipment and prep times needed to be altered to conform to the
realities of the U.S. infrastructure.
Beard Papa’s focus on making the world’s
best cream puff goes back to its founder, Mr. Hirota. Before Hirota founded
Muginoho, he worked in the bakery business and ran a small chain of high-end
bakeries that produced a range of various breads. He grew frustrated with
the forced losses his business incurred; whatever was not sold at the end
of the day had to be thrown out. Such losses cut into his marginal profits.
So, Hirota decided to create one exceptional product.
Inspired by his own childhood love of cream puffs, he began to focus on
producing and selling the world’s best cream puffs. His devotion to
this singular goal produced the Beard Papa’s phenomenon—fresh,
delicious, all natural, and extremely popular cream puffs.
To produce a premium quality product while keeping
costs under control, Hirota and his team developed a series of mechanized
factories that cut labor costs and produced prepackaged boxes of the cream
puff’s constituent parts. The puff’s shell comes from frozen
dough balls that are made in the factory. The creamy filling is made in the
stores using Madagascar vanilla beans. “A lot of companies cut costs
by using vanilla essence or extract,” says Inagaki. “We take
the vanilla bean, slice it in the middle, and scrape out the seeds.
That’s why you can see black bits in the custard itself.” Beard
Papa’s maintains that using these premium ingredients create a taste
premium that sets the product above its Japanese competitors.
As Inagaki noted, there is also an element of theater
to a Beard Papa’s operation. Unlike a typical bakery where a product
is simply plucked off the shelf when a customer places an order, Beard
Papa’s prepares each puff individually for each customer. It is only
when the customer purchases the cream puff that the cream is injected into
the pastry shell. There is a practical reason for this as well—a last
minute cream injection keeps the pastry shell crisp, the cream fresh, and
the whole puff from getting soggy.
Beard Papa’s also takes action to ensure product
standardization across locations. One out of every five cream puffs is
weighed to ensure that the proper amount of cream has been added to the
shell. “If a cream puff is off the standard weight by more than 5
grams, we either throw that pastry away or keep it for the staff. Part of
what makes a franchise a franchise is the maintenance of the same product
and quality in all stores. We make sure that the cream puff tastes the same
even if we have to use sugar or flour from different suppliers. To obtain
this consistency required more than 3,000 trial-and-error tests,” says
Inagaki.
Market research leads executives to believe that Beard
Papa’s cream puffs will find an enthusiastic consumer base in many
countries—particularly the U.S. and Europe.
As evidence, Takuma Ogihara (no relation to Nobuko
Ogihara), part of Beard Papa’s franchising and expansion team, tells
the story of one lactose-intolerant New Yorker. According to Ogihara, the
customer regularly brings Beard Papa’s puffs to parties, saves one or
two to eat right at the end of the party before heading home to endure his
subsequent distress in private. The same guy is so impressed with the
popularity of the puffs, says Ogihara, that he’s even thinking of
opening his own store.
Though Beard Papa’s now receives requests
from would-be franchisees across the country, the company is taking its
expansion slowly. “You can’t have a store opening on every
corner in an environment where people are not yet used to eating cream
puffs,” explains Inagaki. Indeed, while cream puffs are popular, even
ubiquitous, treats in Japan, Beard Papa’s will have to create a
market in the States. Still, Beard Papa’s is looking at opening five
or six stores in Manhattan and expanding to other major cities like Los Angeles,
Chicago, D.C., Boston, and Dallas.
Company executives say a lack of shareholder
pressures is a major asset in allowing Beard Papa’s to expand at its
own pace. “A public company like Krispy Kreme has a lot of pressure
from its shareholders to boost sales every quarter no matter what. This
leads the company to start selling its products in gas stations,
supermarkets, and delis. While this is great in a way, you also lose
control over the product. You don’t know how long it is sitting on
the shelf,” says Takuma Ogihara. Beard Papa’s has no plans to
go public at this point and thus can keep greater control over the
presentation, sales, and freshness of its products—and thus over its
brand and reputation, explains Ogihara.
Still, the company is not trying to stifle creativity
once it does begin franchising. Though every franchisee will be expected
to maintain quality and service standards, individual operators will have
choices. Some Beard Papa’s stores might sell cheesecake-on-a-stick
once domestic manufacturing facilities for the product is set up. And,
franchisees will be encouraged to try different cream flavors—after
gaining approval from corporate headquarters. “We recommend for
franchisees to try our flavor varieties— like vanilla, dark
chocolate, and coffee. But if they can explain why eggplant-flavored cream
puffs might work in North Dakota, and the flavor gains approval, then
that’s okay,” says Ogihara.
Right now, Beard Papa’s occupies center stage in
the American cream puff scene, but as the company raises its profile, it
might find other entrepreneurs competing for a piece of the same puff. A
new Japanese-owned cream puff shop, Choux Factory, opened in August and
began establishing its own customer base in New York City. (Choux Factory
takes its name from the French word choux that describes the type of pastry
shell used in the puffs. In Japan, the pastries are known as
“choux-cream.”)
Choux Factory’s Executive Director Yoko Kato
says her cream puff shop will develop its own following in the cream puff
business based on the strength of a thick, handmade egg custard filling (purposefully
free of vanilla beans) and a baked shell topped with caramelized cinnamon
and sugar. To complement the puffs, Choux Factory has developed a specialty-grade
Hawaiian Kona coffee blend, the highest grade of coffee on the market.
Kato believes there’s plenty of room in New York
for two cream puff chains. Choux Factory plans to open a second store by
the end of the year and then expand from there on a corporate-ownership
model.
The thought of such competition doesn’t seem to
worry Beard Papa’s, which has carved out a reputation as a purveyor
of premium puffs in its own crowded Japanese market. Indeed, Beard
Papa’s team says it welcomes other puff sellers. Anything to increase
familiarity.
“In America, many people don’t even know
what a cream puff is,” says Inagaki. “Unlike deep-fried
doughnuts, cream puffs are baked pastries, so they are much healthier.
Everything is made fresh and is all-natural with no additives and no food
coloring.
“We want people to wake up in the morning and
replace their soggy, greasy, unhealthy donuts with fresh cream puffs and
coffee. Sooner or later, we want companies to replace their coffee rooms
with cream puff rooms.”
Aaron Dalton has written on health, food, and business
for many magazines and covers People stories in QSR. Contact him at
aaron@imaginationwins.com