Special Report | October 2012 | By Sam Oches

2012 QSR Drive-Thru Study

Page 2
Taco Bell has the second fastest drive thru in quick service.

“With speed, we’ve actually shifted our focus away from total transaction time and are focusing just on the window time, and within window time, we’re focusing less on the average and more on the distribution,” Pendergast says. “I don’t know that another 10 seconds makes a huge difference to a guest, but if we can eliminate the five-minute, seven-minute, [and] 10-minute transaction entirely, that, I think, will drive a more meaningful customer satisfaction.”

Speed is also relative among the benchmark chains. While Wendy’s, Taco Bell, Bojangles’, Krystal, and Burger King all had fewer than two vehicles on average in the drive thru, McDonald’s and Chick-fil-A—Nos. 5 and 6, respectively, in drive-thru service time—each had more than double that (Chick-fil-A had a whopping 5.37 vehicles on average).

“We always look for opportunities to increase capacity and improve accuracy,” writes McDonald’s spokeswoman Danya Proud in an e-mail to QSR. “Finding ways to make the drive-thru easier for our employees to operate and having greater capability to meet the needs of our customer is always a top priority.”

How to manage capacity

In the last several years, McDonald’s and Chick-fil-A have each attempted to ease the strains of busy drive thrus by employing a two-lane system in many units. These operations split cars into two ordering stations, after which the lanes flow back into one line for payment and pick-up.

“Growing the drive-thru business requires matching the capacity of a drive-thru layout with the customer demand,” Proud writes in her e-mail. “Multiple lanes provide the ability to have multiple order points, which is an effective way to increase the number of guests a restaurant can serve.”

Though such a system has worked effectively for McDonald’s and Chick-fil-A, other brands interviewed for this story admit that, while it’s something they’ve explored, customers pulling through their drive thrus shouldn’t expect to see multiple lanes any time soon.

“Multiple lanes and windows are helpful to alleviate bottlenecks,” writes Rob Savage, chief operating officer of Taco Bell, in an e-mail to QSR. “However, our experience has shown that these solutions can be expensive to implement and are only used situationally.”

Rather than invest the capital in multiple drive-thru lanes, many brands are exploring the idea of the line buster. Representatives of McDonald’s, Bojangles’, Krystal, and Wendy’s all confirmed that line-busting technologies are either used or in development throughout their systems. While Lynch says Wendy’s employed line busters as many as 30 years ago to keep the drive-thru line moving, innovations in tablet and POS technology have given operators new opportunities to streamline through an outside order-taker.

“When you’re in a situation where you’ve got great volume, great velocity, and you need to get more cars in and off your lot, an outside order-taker can be one of those things that can help you do that,” Bojangles’ Avery says. “That outside order-taker [also] allows us to be more accurate, because we’re having that person interact directly with the customer and then relaying that inside in our language, so we know exactly what our customers want to get it right.”

Meanwhile, executives at Krystal have their eye on other futuristic ideas to help improve efficiencies in drive-thru capacity. Pendergast says he could see mobile ordering finding its way to the Krystal drive thru soon.

“[I see] the ability of a customer to either call ahead or interface with us on an iPhone application, say, ‘I’m going to be by between 2 o’clock and 2:15, I’d like 48 Krystals to go,’ and to have those items prepared and in place, perhaps using their iPhones to make that payment already,” he says. “All they have to do is swing around, pick it up, and they’re off and running.”

The most crucial element in drive thru?

Pendergast says that at Krystal, cleanliness is one of the most critical elements to the drive thru—even as he admits the company could be doing a better job with it.

The good news for Pendergast and other operators is they seem to be doing a fine job at cleanliness. Data shows that at least 98.3 percent of the exteriors of each surveyed chain’s units were “favorable.” Similarly, no brand did worse than 98.7 percent on menuboard cleanliness, while 99.4 percent or more of units at each surveyed brand had clean temporary signage.

But that doesn’t mean companies can rest easy on the cleanliness front. Pendergast says Krystal has a system-wide cleanliness program that involves training, measurement, and preventative maintenance, and that the company is tripling the frequency with which in-house maintenance teams visit restaurants.

Bojangles’ has a similar commitment, as its managers do a walk-through of their units every hour to make sure everything is spic-and-span. “Customers that are visiting your drive thru are not coming inside, so they make impressions of your business and how you execute based on how you keep the outside, the landscaping, the drive-thru lanes, the windows at the pick-up window, Dumpster gates, all of that stuff,” Avery says.

Dumpster gates seem to be the one cleanliness component currently lacking in the drive-thru industry. According to the Performance Study, the vast majority of units’ Dumpsters are visible from the menuboard. A full 94.2 percent of Bojangles’ units have a visible Dumpster, while Burger King has the lowest amount, at 66.4 percent.

Shaping the customer’s purchasing decision

Drive-thru menuboards and temporary signage may be clean across the quick-service industry, but benchmark brands are working diligently to strategically use signage to maximize the drive thru.

“We’ve decluttered a lot of our menuboards, making them easy to read for customers,” Avery says. “We think if they’re easy to read, from font size and pictures and whatever the case may be, that they can order quicker and we can keep the line moving.”

Krystal is also using its signage to improve upon the drive-thru experience. Pendergast says it’s working with business partner Coca-Cola to transform the menuboard so it’s organized better, with different bundles and revised pricing structures.

“We believe, in addition to the marketing and promotions, that the pre-sell board and the menuboard are the key tools we have to shape and influence the customer’s purchasing decision,” he says. “So we’re looking to make it easier for them to buy what they’d like to buy; easier to evaluate their choices; and encouraging them to buy items that we think will drive not only satisfaction, but will be efficient for the kitchen and the team to execute.”

With the exception of Chick-fil-A, benchmark brands continue to put a heavy investment in another visual tool: order confirmation boards (ocb). Every brand in the benchmark group increased its percentage of units with an OCB (even Chick-fil-A went from 8 percent of units with an OCB to 12.2 percent this year).

“We’ve found that customers truly appreciate seeing their order keyed in right after they order it, and that helps them make certain that they’ve said everything they wanted,” Wendy’s Lynch says. “Sometimes customers forget that they wanted a Frosty, or they forget to tell us. So it’s verification, but it’s also verification that the employee heard them correctly and keyed it in correctly.”



Sam, is there a complete ranking on line? Thanks, Scott@flip-n-burgers

I will take freshness and quality over speed every time!

The Drive Thru technology world is a growing place. The Summit Pure Timing System has world first technology that enables restaurants to Rank and Compte LIVE and AS IT HAPPENS. this dynamic system has been outstanding growth in the Asutralian Market and now in the central American Market. Operators are claiming the live Dynamic Summit Ranking system is respnsible for sales growth and increases in on floor motivatation and productivity. The Summit Pure Timing System has a both the interactive ranking but a dynamic timing screen that enables as it happens shift management raction. agian operational imprevement and sales growth for the operator. This cutting edge system also enables operators, area managers and head office staff to view live reports from the Ipad, Iphone and android systems. enabling you to react now, not tomorrow. the live ranking is also part of the summit system on your remote systems. to find out more please contact me on [email protected] . - Chris Close, Director, Global Operations. Summit has also expanded operations into BK in Dallas and signed a national installation platform. www.summitaustralia.com.au

Thank you Chick-fil-A for setting standards in more ways than one. Your teams are my heroes and I do mean your front line teams and your adherence to your core corporate philosophy. Very nice to see, Competent, Nice and Dedication lead an industry. My best to you.

Del Taco is the FASTEST. At least my Del Taco is. Crazy fast drive thru line.

That's great. The two Del Tacos where I lived in CA were both ridiculously slow. At least I got hot food.

they all cheat anyway. can you pull off to the side and have someone bring it out for you?

Of all the companies I've ever written to with a complaint, comment, or suggestion, Burger King is the ONLY one who didn't respond to my complaint with at least a letter of apology and/or a coupon for a future visit. I will say that the situation at my local BK improved, so maybe my letter did some good, even if BK didn't acknowledge it.

Do you just go around complaining all the time?

Speed and accuracy, the twin brothers of a successful drive-thru operation that optimizes efficiency with customer-friendly effectiveness. Learn how our state-of-the-art order confirmation systems, drive-thru lane timing systems, and DACT headset system integrated into a single and optimal solution can provide a unique data set that will help you improve your operation and provide a customer friendly drive-thru experience in the shortest possible time. To learn more, contact me at [email protected] or check out Delphi Display Systems' website at www.delphidisplay.com.

I can vouch for Wendy's efforts at improving service times. They do it in a number of ways. First, everyone wears a headset. That way, if you're not busy, you can pitch in to assist the drive-thru by setting up the frozen desserts or something else. Second, the crew is assigned to certain duties but, in case of a bottleneck, are moved to another area to assist until the problem is handled. Third, over the past few years, they have installed timers in the stores that track the customer service times from the second the customer arrives at the drive-thru menu board until they drive off. These timers record how long the customer is at the menu board, how long the customer is in the drive-thru line after ordering, how long the customer waits at the drive-thru window waiting to receive their order and how long it takes them to clear the drive-thru area. Additionally, cashiers have change ready before the customer arrives at their window and, at the second window, all the condiments and paper goods are stocked for quick packing and service. No one in the drive-thru service team is to leave the service to retrieve paper goods, condiments, etc, because someone outside of the drive-thru area is assigned that chore. Managers are encouraged to set up contests for the fastest service time during a certain time period, ie. a week. It's very much team-oriented and is taken very seriously. Managers are always involved with this service, too. There is no such nthing as a manager sitting in the office during a rush period.

in my neighborhood which is considered among the poorer area we have mcdonalds and a wendys side by side both very modern but mcdonalds out sells wendys 5 to 1. Could someone tell me why?

Wendy only won, because they interrupt you several times while you try to order.

Wendy's may be fast, but unfortunately the food is horrible. Not only do they not put out the correct orders, the food is of the poorest quality!!!! I would much rather wait longer food foodthat is edible than to get bad food fast!!!!

Agreed. Wendy's may be fast, but their food is one of the worst. Its too bad because I remember liking Wendy's years ago. Bring the old food back.


Add new comment