Over the past 12 months, I’ve talked with restaurant marketers across the food franchise space, and a clear theme came through: a wave of new expectations is being placed on them by their brands. They were all pretty unified that they are under tremendous pressure, and the strongest pressure point is showing unit-level performance within 90 days. Unit-level economics is what keeps franchisees, CEOs, boards, and private equity at ease, and marketers are expected to move that number fast.
If they can’t show that number moving in the right direction, they will not be granted time to develop new creative that builds brand momentum, improve their tech stack, or address anything else. These are the items marketers used to tackle first to bring cohesiveness and structure to a brand. Now, time limits in the role have pushed them to the back burner. No room to build, no room to fix, no room for anything but survival.
Under this pressure, marketers need a new mode of support from their agency partners. They don’t need another report or another promise. They need a partner willing to share the risk, not just the credit, when the results come in.
A 150-Year-Old Model
The modern agency relationship traces back to Philadelphia. In the 1870s, N.W. Ayer & Son introduced the “open contract,” which put the agent squarely on the advertiser’s side instead of playing a balancing act between channel rep and brand rep. In the 150 years since, the basic advertising agency model for performance and compensation has stayed the same. The agency buys media, reports on deliverables like impressions and clicks, and gets paid either way. We’ve added influencers, creative development, loyalty, and other services along the way, but the model itself hasn’t changed significantly.
The Technology Caught Up
Everything around that model has changed. Attribution has made huge strides since the advent of Google, and with online ordering, media optimization has become far more effective, which leads to better revenue performance at the location level. POS systems and loyalty marketing give brands a closer touch with their guests, which leads to better activation.
Today we can run media location by location, attribute online revenue to each one, and use restaurant data platforms to read the results while factoring in inclement weather and other variables. Influencer marketing is moving toward full attribution, and other media are moving in the same direction. For instance, we are running a social campaign with lead gen activation that sends guests a $5-off-$25 Toast coupon code by SMS, and we’ve validated a 5x return in-store revenue to media spend for this campaign. Stack enough measurable tactics like that together, and you can predict what a location will do. The technology caught up. The agency model hasn’t.
Software Figured This Out Years Ago
Software companies have long let the product prove itself before the customer carries the full risk. Pilots, 90-day trials, and service-level commitments with credits when the vendor falls short are standard in SaaS. The vendor stands behind what it sells because it can measure whether it delivered.
Advertising has not followed, and there is no longer a technical reason why. With food marketers in such a box, isn’t it time for agencies to shoulder more of the burden?
What an Agency Guarantee Could Look Like
Borrow straight from the SaaS playbook. A brand selects a test group of its locations. Each one gets a revenue goal, measured against the same period last year and agreed by the brand and the agency before any work begins. That goal should cover every channel the location has: dine-in, takeout, catering, and third-party delivery. You can also use a third-party data tool, Bikky, Red Onion, or others, to provide an unbiased third-party calculation. The rules for what nobody controls, like weather, closures, and price changes, are agreed up front too, so no one argues about them at the end, and the third-party data mechanism can help support this discussion
The agency’s fees are held in escrow. If the locations hit their goals, the fees are released to the agency. If they don’t, the fees go back to the brand, which covers only the media itself. Either way, in 90 days the marketer gets a fast read on which efforts are moving revenue at the unit level and which aren’t. They can then apply those learnings across the brand.
That mitigates risk for the risk-averse, and who wouldn’t be risk-averse in today’s CMO environment?
We’ve started offering exactly this at MA+A. Before we offered it to a single brand, we looked hard at our own numbers. Across our KPI-aligned engagements, we hit the agreed-upon targets 82 to 88 percent of the time. That isn’t perfect, and it doesn’t need to be. It was enough for us to put our own fees at risk, and I suspect many agencies would find similar numbers if they looked.
Marketing and Operations in the Same Room
A guarantee also changes what happens inside the brand. When the agency’s fees depend on location revenue, marketing, operations, technology, and finance all have to look at the same data. That transparency does more than settle the scorecard. It shows where the guest journey is breaking down.
The brand needs to build a tighter feedback loop. Making sure the entire tech stack is pushing in the same direction and driving an overall mindset change.
That may be the biggest benefit of putting fees on the line. A performance guarantee pushes the whole organization to break down silos between marketing and operations, because results only come when both sides are working from the same numbers.
Skin in the Game: The 90-Day Challenge
There are probably other ways to mitigate risk and put performance responsibility on the agency, and I’d welcome them. A 90-day structure is one approach, not the only one. But isn’t now the time for this to happen?
For too many years, agencies have kept themselves out of the line of fire. With the way media can now be delivered, measured, and optimized, that is no longer defensible. When the agency’s fees ride on the same number the marketer is judged by, everyone is finally working toward the same result. It is time for agencies to have skin in the game alongside the brand marketers they serve.
Bob McKay is the CEO and Founder of McKay Advertising + Activation, founded in 2005. MA+A has become known as the Franchise Whisperers for food brands. They developed the Activation Bridge, which takes brands from non-attributable ROI models to attributable ROI models at the location level.
