Guests might love your restaurant brand more than ever. They might recommend you to their friends, give you glowing reviews, and rank you above every competitor in your category. And yet, they may be visiting half as often.

Restaurant leaders know consumers are feeling the financial squeeze. They’re watching transaction counts, average checks, and visit frequency while trying to determine how much of the decline is economic and how much reflects changing brand preference. Yet the loyalty metrics they rely on don’t always make that distinction clear. 

It creates a serious challenge for operators trying to understand the performance of their brands. It also deserves consideration when evaluating one of the most influential theories in loyalty research.

Loyalty Metrics Aren’t Perfect

In a 2011 Harvard Business Review article, Timothy Keiningham and his fellow researchers challenged conventional wisdom in how loyalty is measured and evaluated. The research found that popular loyalty measures, including guest satisfaction and Net Promoter Score (NPS), had surprisingly weak relationships with how consumers allocated their spending in reality.

Their alternative, named the Wallet Allocation Rule, demonstrated that a brand’s relative ranking among competitors was substantially more predictive of its share of guest spending. 

The principle is compelling. Here’s how it plays out: A guest might be perfectly satisfied with your restaurant while preferring three competitors. Their satisfaction tells you relatively little about how much of their business you’ll actually capture. Keiningham’s research helped expose the dangerous assumption that satisfied guests are simultaneously commercially loyal guests. 

However, restaurant leaders should be equally skeptical of treating share of wallet as the definitive measure of loyalty. The research was conducted before a global pandemic dismantled established dining routines. It was conducted before digital ordering became such a dominant force in restaurant transactions, and before years of inflation fundamentally changed how consumers evaluate everyday purchases.

The original principle remains valuable, but the conditions under which guests act on their preferences have changed considerably. And it’s complicated efforts to explain declining restaurant spending through competitive preference alone.

Guests Aren’t Necessarily Leaving. They’re Spending Less.

According to the National Restaurant Association’s third-quarter 2026 consumer research, 50 percent of consumers reported greater difficulty covering their expenses than a year earlier. Forty percent said they were using more discounts and value promotions than usual. And it’s absolutely showing up in purchasing behavior.

To compound the issue, McKinsey’s January 2026 restaurant research found that consumers planning to reduce restaurant spending generally preferred cutting back at their favorite restaurants through smaller orders, cheaper items, or promotions rather than abandoning those restaurants for lower-priced competitors. Suffice to say, the game has changed notably. 

Here’s how that plays out: A guest who previously visited your restaurant weekly may now visit twice a month. They might skip the appetizer or share an entrée with someone else. Their average check declines, their annual spending falls, and their transaction frequency deteriorates.

By all conventional commercial measures, that guest looks less loyal. Yet their preference for your brand may be entirely intact. This is where the distinction between brand preference and economic capacity becomes a noticeable and critical factor. 

Consumers today are affected by the largest credit card debt per household ever experienced. And buy-now-pay-later services aren’t super relevant to food purchases. That leaves people with an inarguable fact: You can’t spend money you don’t have, regardless of how strongly you prefer the food, service, or experience.

The result is a reality where a brand can also maintain or increase its share of a guest’s restaurant spending while generating less revenue from that guest. Capturing a larger slice of a shrinking pie makes for an encouraging percentage and a disappointing income statement.

What compounds the issue is the state of ordering takeout or eating out of home has also changed the competitive landscape for restaurants.

Your Biggest Competitor Might Be a Grocery Store or C-Store

Restaurant leaders spend enormous amounts of time studying direct competitors. They analyze menus, evaluate pricing, monitor promotions, and keep a close eye on the trades to stay ahead of what other restaurant brands are doing. Meanwhile, grocers and convenience stores are making increasingly compelling arguments for why guests should be spending their food dollars elsewhere.

The days of dismissing grocery-prepared meals and gas station food as inferior alternatives are numbered. Grocers are expanding their selections of freshly prepared meals, while convenience brands like Wawa, Sheetz, and Casey’s have built substantial foodservice businesses around made-to-order sandwiches, pizza, and other restaurant-style offerings.

According to FMI, The Food Industry Association, the share of shoppers substituting grocery deli-prepared foods for restaurant meals more than doubled from 12 percent in 2017 to 28 percent in 2025. Its 2026 research also found that 56 percent of households combine home preparation with food prepared outside the home for dinner at least once a week.

Convenience stores are making equally significant investments. The National Association of Convenience Stores reported that foodservice accounted for 28.5 percent of in-store sales and nearly 39 percent of in-store gross profit dollars in 2025. Prepared foods, including pizza, chicken, sandwiches, and salads, represented nearly three-quarters of foodservice sales.

The economic pressures facing guests only intensify this competition. McKinsey reported that restaurant and takeout prices increased approximately 6 percent between January 2024 and September 2025, compared with roughly 3 percent for groceries.

A family might still consider your restaurant its favorite fast-casual destination but decide that spending $65 on dinner isn’t financially sensible this week. Instead, they pick up a freshly prepared meal from their local grocer or grab something from a nearby convenience store. They’ve found an alternative that satisfies the occasion without requiring them to cook or compromise substantially on convenience.

For restaurant leaders, understanding share of wallet requires a more expansive view of the competition. Grocers and convenience stores are actively pursuing the same meal occasions, often with products that have little resemblance to the prepared-food offerings of a decade ago. Ignoring them risks misunderstanding where guests are actually taking their business.

The Pandemic Permanently Shifted Behaviors

The pandemic also changed the circumstances under which guests encounter restaurant brands. Before 2020, office commutes, predictable lunch breaks, school schedules, and established family routines created dependable dining occasions.

Today, hybrid work has reduced the frequency of some workplace dining occasions. Guests who once visited the same restaurant three times a week may now work from home several days. Their spending declines even if their preference remains unchanged.

Digital ordering has complicated the relationship further. The National Restaurant Association reported that nearly 75 percent of restaurant traffic was off-premises in its 2025 research. Guests increasingly choose among restaurants through websites, apps, third-party marketplaces, and delivery platforms.

A guest might prefer your brand’s food but repeatedly order from a competitor because its digital experience is easier, delivery is faster, or pickup is more dependable. The guest hasn’t necessarily changed their opinion of your restaurant. The competitive circumstances surrounding the transaction have changed.

Physical proximity, digital convenience, household budgets, and dining occasions all influence whether preference becomes a purchase. A relative preference ranking cannot fully explain those barriers.

Stop Diagnosing Every Revenue Problem as a Loyalty Problem

Restaurant executives need measurement systems capable of distinguishing changes in guest preference from changes in purchasing behavior. Declining frequency might indicate weakening brand preference. It could also reflect reduced purchasing power, changed routines, fewer relevant occasions, or increased competition from meals prepared at home.

These problems have different causes and demand different responses. If guests are choosing competitors because of poor food quality or service, the brand has a legitimate competitive problem. If guests prefer your restaurant but cannot justify visiting as frequently, the response may involve menu architecture, value engineering, accessible price points, or creating additional occasions. If guests prefer your food but abandon orders because your digital experience is cumbersome, offering more loyalty points won’t solve the underlying problem.

And since the entire restaurant category is losing occasions to grocery and c-store alternatives, a brand can improve its competitive ranking while continuing to experience pressure on traffic.

Restaurant leaders generally understand these pressures. The challenge is determining which ones are responsible for the changes appearing in their performance reports. When loyalty metrics are interpreted without sufficient economic, behavioral, and competitive context, they can encourage investments that fail to address the underlying problem.

Keiningham’s research made an important contribution by challenging the industry’s reliance on satisfaction scores. Fifteen years later, restaurant leaders should bring that same skepticism to their interpretation of share of wallet, visit frequency, and loyalty-program performance.

There is no definitive post-pandemic replication establishing whether the Wallet Allocation Rule’s original predictive relationships have strengthened or weakened. But the behavioral and economic changes of the last six years give us sufficient reason to question how broadly we apply them.

Restaurant brands should measure competitive preference alongside guest penetration, category participation, purchase occasions, and economic constraints. Those distinctions help determine whether a brand is losing its appeal or whether guests are losing opportunities to act on that appeal.

Before spending another dollar trying to convince guests to love your restaurant more, make sure their feelings are actually the problem causing the declined or stagnated sales.

Joseph Szala is Vice President at 3Owl, where he leads strategy, creative direction, and digital experience for restaurant brands that refuse to blend in. With a foundation in hospitality and a focus on scalable digital experience platforms, he helps restaurant brands lead in the digital age.

Marketing & Promotions, Outside Insights, Story, Technology